One of the best organic eye makeup removers for removing waterproof eye makeup is the Camomile Gentle Eye Makeup Remover from The Body Shop. Its main ingredient is organic camomile essential oil and it also contains refreshing rose water and moisturizing vegetable glycerin. These ingredients help soothe and soften the eye area without irritation and without making the eyelashes brittle and weak. It is not very cheap it is for $14.50 for an eight ounce bottle.
Put some of the eye makeup remover on a cotton pad, press it to your eyes for a minute or two and then remove the makeup. But only a little amount of product should be used as too much of it can cause some redness. It will glide of easily without resorting to any rubbing. It does not cause any stinging in the eyes and there is no oily or sticky residue afterwards either. In most of the eye makeup removers you are left with an annoying oiliness.
The gentle eye makeup remover though great for removing normal eye makeup does not do well with waterproof mascaras. If wearing waterproof mascara you have to use it two or three times to completely take off the mascara.